These sentences from CropLife's letter were particularly noteworthy:
Technology in agriculture has allowed for the development of much of what we know and use in our lives today. If Americans were still required to farm to support their family's basic food and fiber needs, would the U.S. have been leaders in the advancement of science, communication, education, medicine, transportation, and the arts?
["Transportation"? Really? Good thing they didn't include finance on this list. But it does raise questions about the legitimacy of the overall claim, doesn't it...]
We live in a very different world than that of our grandparents. Americans are juggling jobs with the needs of children and aging parents. The time needed to tend a garden is not there for the majority of our citizens, certainly not a garden of sufficient productivity to supply much of a family's year-round food need
On the one hand, it seems, our "liberation" from the farm has permitted us unparalleled freedom to develop advances in every area of life. On the other hand, it seems, we are so damned busy in our liberated lifestyles - "juggling jobs with the needs of children and aging parents" - that there just isn't time to tend even a family garden, even if one wanted to. The beautiful chains that adorn us all - from commuters to soccer moms - freed from the necessity of farming, yet having no time to garden!
I compare these sentiments to a several passages written in 1853 by Henry Lester, a Vermont farmer. The essay is entitled "Man Made For Agriculture" and won the award of "Premium Essay" at the Rutland County Fair of that year. It is reproduced as an appendix of a fine book written by Professor Charles Fish - a person of long acquaintance, but whom I have not seen in some time, alas - entitled In Good Hands: The Keeping of a Family Farm. (Read a wonderful review of Fish's book by my teacher, Wilson Carey McWilliams, here. Carey introduced me to Charles Fish more years ago than I can count, half-appropriately enough at the New England Political Science conference). Just over a century and a half ago, Henry Lester wrote,
"To make a man long-lived, it is necessary that he should have pure air, pure water, wholesome food used in reasonable quantities, a regular systematic diet and habits, temperance in all things, be cheerful and contented with his occupation, rise early and be industrious, and never complain of his hard lot, his poor occupation. In fine he must not sigh for the fleshpots of Egypt. He must [be] thankful that the supreme being created him and ordained him for an agriculturalist, placed him on goodly soil in a good country, surrounded by a good society of his fellows in genial clime where hill, dale, and mountain forest, the grasses, fruit and grains make the scenery both desirable and beautiful....
"Young men and maidens, agriculture is your most safe employment, the most sure of competence, long life, and happiness. But few fail that pursue this with alacrity, when in the mercantile and other professions, but few are prospered, and those few mostly, whether statesmen, jurists, or merchant princes, retire at last to agriculture that their last days be serene and happy. Again, agriculture not only being the most useful, healthful, and independent occupation, tends more than any other to lead the mind to religion, morality, and virtue, and make man feel and act towards his fellow man like the good Samaritan, and how few educated in the rural districts in schools and high schools, and learn and follow the agricultural profession through their minority, fall into vicious habits and are [a] curse to themselves and community thereafter....
"Further, the agriculturalist, raising most things for their own use and for the support of all, is the most independent class. They have the creator's promise that seedtime and harvest shall not fail. They are the grand conservators of freedom and democracy throughout the world. On their will rests the continuance of this republic. "
Yes, one can only marvel at CropLife's claims that we have gained so much in leaving the land - that great freedom to juggle jobs and burdened with children and old people whose care many seek to farm out to low-paid labor. Thank goodness we are all so "free."